We Buy Cars

Johnstons Subaru Wants to Buy Your Car

When you're looking to move on from your current vehicle, you might be tempted by a private sale. While a private sale can certainly offer you total control over the sale of your car, it comes with its fair share of headaches that can make navigating the process challenging and frustrating. Why not make the experience easy and enjoyable by selling your vehicle to Johnstons Subaru! We buy all makes and models, and we'll buy from you even if you don't buy from us! We're happy to be a lease return center as well - we are just looking to add exceptional used vehicles to our inventory! Check out the process and see how easy it can be!


Lease Return Center

Did you know you can return your lease to Johnstons Subaru even if it's not a lease from this store and even if it's not a Subaru? Our goal is to make your transition from your lease as seamless as possible. Stop by and return your lease with us!


Your Car has Never Been Worth More

With the current landscape of the car market there has never been a better time for you to sell your vehicle. This bubble will not last forever, so sell to us today and get your best deal. We'll buy from you even if you don't buy from us! 

Want to Talk Auto Finance?

We take care of everything when you sell your vehicle at Johnstons Subaru. We want you to get the best value for your vehicle, which is why we're happy to guide you through the steps!

First, we'll need some basic information on your car. Using our online trade-in tool, you can discover the value of your vehicle based on factors like make, model, mileage, model year, condition, and features. This information will be used to provide an estimate for your car, truck, or SUV

Next, you'll need to make an appointment with our team for an in-person appraisal. We'll need to inspect your vehicle and ensure that you're getting the best possible value for your vehicle. At this time, we'll come up with a final offer.

Lastly, once you accept the offer, you'll get a check for the amount! You can use this amount towards a trade-in from our inventory, or you can pocket the check and use it as you see fit! We're happy to help you search for a new vehicle, but we'll also buy your vehicle even if you don't buy from us!

Ready to get started?

Fill out the information on the form down below or visit us here at Johnstons Subaru and see how much your vehicle is worth today!

Sell Your Vehicle

  1. Johnstons Subaru

    3480 Route 6
    Middletown, NY 10940

    • Sales: (845) 344-3100
Loading Map...

Get in Touch

  • Contact our Sales Department at: (845) 344-3100
  • Monday9:00am - 6:00pm
  • Tuesday9:00am - 6:00pm
  • Wednesday9:00am - 6:00pm
  • Thursday9:00am - 6:00pm
  • Friday9:00am - 6:00pm
  • Saturday9:00am - 5:00pm
  • SundayClosed