Jennifer Wong
04/15/2026
Restored my experience on buying a used car. Robbie was my sales person and he was great. I am very happy with my purchase and the process was seamless and very professional. I highly recommend them.
Used Vehicles Under $25K Inventory For Sale In Middletown, NY
If you're shopping on a strict budget, our inventory of used cars under $25,000 could have exactly what you're looking for. Browse our impressive selection below, then visit Johnstons Subaru in Middletown, NY, for a test drive.
Johnstons Subaru
Local Car dealer Selling New Subaru and Used Cars.
Serving: Middletown, NY, Newburgh, NY, Monroe, NY, Warwick, NY, and Port Jervis, NY.
Directions
Local Phone: 877-557-7452
Local Car dealer Selling New Subaru and Used Cars.
Serving: Middletown, NY, Newburgh, NY, Monroe, NY, Warwick, NY, and Port Jervis, NY.
Directions
Local Phone: 877-557-7452
� � ���
243 Dolson Ave
��� Middletown
��� NY
��� 10940
* Although every reasonable effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained on this site, absolute accuracy cannot be guaranteed. This site, and all information and materials appearing on it, are presented to the user "as is" without warranty of any kind, either express or implied, including but not limited to the implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose, title or non-infringement. All vehicles are subject to prior sale. Price does not include applicable tax, title or license. Not responsible for typographical errors.
**The arrival timeline is an estimate. It may vary due to circumstances beyond Subaru’s or the retailer’s control.
**The arrival timeline is an estimate. It may vary due to circumstances beyond Subaru’s or the retailer’s control.
The Answer to Your "Used Cars Under $25K Near Me" Search
Our selection of used cars under $25K for sale gives you plenty of ways to find a vehicle that fits your needs without stretching your spending range. From efficient sedans to spacious SUVs, our inventory typically includes a variety of Subaru models from different model years and at different trim levels. This allows you to access more premium configurations without paying a new-car price.
Read on to learn more about the sedans and SUVs we tend to have in stock. However, keep in mind that our inventory rotates as we sell cars and take in trades, so check back often if you're holding out for something really specific.
Explore Our Collection of Used Sedans Under $25K
Do you prefer a vehicle that's easy to maneuver, fuel-efficient, and comfortable to drive while commuting in the city or going on a road trip? A used sedan can be your answer. Although our inventory is constantly changing, we typically stock popular Subaru sedan models, including the Impreza and Legacy.
Are you interested in rally-inspired design? You may even spot a Subaru WRX on our lot, though you should act fast if you do.
Additionally, depending on the used Subaru under $25,000 you choose, you can enjoy plenty of modern amenities, such as touchscreen infotainment, smartphone integration, heated seats, and advanced driver-assistance technology. It's hard to beat a Subaru for a reliable commuter near Newburgh, NY, that has your back during the winter months, and our selection is curated to make it easy to find your ideal fit.
Find Used SUVs Under $25,000
While the sedans in our used Subaru lineup provide a sensible means of transportation, our collection of used SUVs under $25,000 can give you the space and utility you're after. Whether you have a growing family or an active social life full of road trips, popular models like the Subaru Forester, Crosstrek, and Ascent offer plenty of seating and flexible cargo options.
Looking for a versatile SUV at an accessible price? A used Forester under $25,000 can provide a comfortable cabin, useful cargo space, and the capability Subaru is known for. For drivers who prefer a smaller footprint, a used Crosstrek under $25,000 offers a nice balance of SUV versatility and easy maneuverability, making it a practical choice for everyday driving.
Shop for a Used Subaru for Sale Under $25,000 at Johnstons Subaru
Browse our current inventory of used cars under $25K for sale. Johnstons Subaru is conveniently located near Warwick, NY. Visit us for a test drive soon!
We have been proudly serving Orange County, NY, and the surrounding communities for many years, and our team can help you narrow down your choices and streamline the financing process. Once you've settled on the vehicle you want and put some miles on it, our service center can provide the maintenance your vehicle needs on the road.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which used Subaru models are best for long-distance travel?
If you spend a lot of time on the road, a used Subaru Forester or Outback can be a great choice. Both offer comfortable seating, plenty of cargo space, and standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive for added confidence along the way. If you prefer something smaller, a used Impreza is easy to drive and still provides plenty of everyday practicality.
Are used Subaru vehicles safe?
Yes, used Subaru vehicles are generally well-regarded for their safety. Many models come with Subaru EyeSight driver-assistance technology, while features like all-wheel drive can provide added traction. Safety features vary by model and trim, so check the specific vehicle for features such as Automatic Emergency Braking, Adaptive Cruise Control, and Lane-Departure Warning.
What should I check before buying a used Subaru?
Before buying a used Subaru vehicle, check its maintenance history, mileage, overall condition, and a CARFAX® Vehicle History Report™. During your test drive, pay attention to how the vehicle accelerates, brakes, and handles, and check for any warning lights. It's also a good idea to have a trusted mechanic inspect the vehicle, especially if you're considering an older or higher-mileage Subaru.
